Follow us on Google News
Get the latest updates directly in your Google News feed
Denis Villeneuve’sDune: Part Twohas been regarded as the filmmaker’s masterpiece and has been reigning at the box office since its release earlier in March. With $577 million at the global box office, the film has become the highest-grossing film of the year. Based on Frank Herbert’s novel series, the film starred Timothée Chalamet and Zendaya in lead roles.
While most critics and fans have been applauding Villeneuve’s vision for the sci-fi epic, there have been criticisms of the movie regarding its depiction of people hailing from MENA backgrounds. Critics noted the absence of significant members of Middle Eastern and North African descent in speaking roles, despite the films being inspired heavily by the cultures of the region and people.
Dune: Part TwoCriticized For Lack Of MENA Representation
Apart from its grand world-building and faithful adaptation of Frank Herbert’s iconic novels,Denis Villeneuve’sDunefranchise boasted a stellar cast with A-list talent. While Timothée Chalamet and Zendaya headlined the film, other stars such as Oscar Isaac, Rebecca Ferguson, Stellan Skarsgård, Javier Bardem, Austin Butler, and Florence Pugh among others featured in the duology.
“It wasn’t meant to be”: Dave Bautista Has 1 Major Regret in Dune 2 That Denis Villeneuve is Partly Responsible for Despite Many Creative Liberties
However, the film has been receiving criticism for not featuring enough actors of MENA descent in the film despite being heavily inspired by Islamic culture, which was present in the novels by Frank Herbert. The Fremen of Arrakis were reportedly inspired by the Bedouins of the Arabic plateau and their fight against their oppressors was reportedly a representation of the Algerians’ revolution against the French (viaVariety).
An article by Furvah Shah inCosmopolitan UKmentioned how the film erased the Middle Eastern and North African influences that the book had. The author wrote,
“From the use of beads and prostration in prayers by the Fremen to the almost-Arabic language, phrases pulled from religious texts, and the wearing of veils, it felt like ‘Dune’ takes a heavy amount of inspiration from Islam, Middle Eastern, and North African cultures yet simultaneously erases us from the screen.”
“One of the most talented Gen Z actors”: Tom Holland Can Only Dream of Breaking a Timothée Chalamet Box Office Record after Wonka, Dune 2
The film still employed many of the MENA influences that were mentioned in the book, such as Lady Jessica’s facial tattoos and the flowing attire of the locals of Arrakis. Arabic words such as the popular ‘Lisan al Gaib’, ‘Mahdi, and others were also used while some were reportedly omitted.
Denis Villeneuve’sDune: Part TwoOnly Had One Actor Of MENA Descent In A Speaking Role
While Denis Villeneuve’sDune: Part Onehad also received similar criticism, no improvements seemed to have been made in the sequel when it came to MENA representation. The film reportedly had only one actor in a speaking role of MENA descent i.e. Souheila Yacoub, a Swiss actress of Tunisian descent. The actress played Shishkali, a Fremen warrior who is often seen with Zendaya’s Chani and Chalamet’s Paul.
A source close to the production mentioned that many of the people of Jordan and Abu Dhabi received apprenticeships and internships on the set of the film as it was being filmed. Reportedly 15 of the 42 Fremen roles were filled by actors of MENA descent, however, only Yacoub had a speaking role (via Variety).
Timothee Chalamet Sets a New Box-Office Record After Dune 2 That Not Even Tom Cruise or Robert Downey Jr. Have Achieved in Their Lifetime
Casting directors noted that it was a missed opportunity by the production house to do more for the community. While Serena Rasoul of MA Casting mentioned that it would have been a great project to show the rich culture of the region, Amani Al-Khatahtbeh of MuslimGirl.com criticized the fact that Hollywood seemed to have a dearth of talented MENA actors when it came to a positive portrayal. She said to Variety,
“One of the big things we hear when it comes to Middle Eastern people getting cast or brown people getting cast is there is not enough talent. Yet there is no hesitation and no challenge for the industry to cast those actors from those backgrounds in the stereotypical roles of being terrorists or villains. Conveniently, we are at a surplus of Middle Eastern actors when it comes to negative portrayal.”
Denis Villeneuve had mentioned while promotingDune: Part Onethat he tried to be faithful to the mages he had in mind while he read the book for the first time as a child. However, he also mentioned that he tried his best to stay true to Frank Herbert’s vision and influences (viaThe Nerds of Color).
Nishanth A
Senior Writer
Articles Published :2419
Nishanth A is a Senior Entertainment Writer at FandomWire, majorly focusing on TV shows with over 2,000 articles published. He has been an entertainment journalist for the past two years and a scriptwriter at various corporations before that, working on educational content. With a Communications, English Literature, and Psychology triple major, Nishanth usually covers news and analyses on Star Trek, particularly Strange New Worlds and The Next Generation; Doctor Who, the DCU, and more.A Nolan fan, Nishanth spends his time exploring the filmographies of various directors with an auteurial style or can be found making short movies of his own. He has also contributed as a feature writer for Film Companion, focusing on the South division.
More from Nishanth A
These 5 Monster Horror Shows Are Like Alien: Earth, but Better
Aubrey Plaza Says This Miles Teller Horror Movie Defined Her Grief After Husband’s Death
Spider-Man: Brand New Day – How the 2008 Comic Arc Could Shape Tom Holland’s Next Movie
Recommended
Gen V Season 2: How Many Episodes Are in the Prime Video Series?
5 Addictive Discord Games That Will Hook Your Whole Squad
Helen Mirren Agrees With Ana de Armas for Next James Bond With Feminist Take
Keeper Trailer: Tatiana Maslany Tries to Survive in Longlegs Director’s Next Horror Flick
Hollow Knight: Silksong Release Set for 2025, Demo Playable at Gamescom
Fact Check: Has Activision Announced Call of Duty: Black Ops Remastered?
Denis Villeneuve
